| Rank | Who | Time |
| Unsubscribed Participant | ||
| 2. | jrduncans | 17 seconds |
| 4 Incognito Achievers | ||
| 7. | Quam 👑 | 25 seconds |
| 8. | sem | 25 seconds |
| 9. | mdrichard05 | 28 seconds |
| 10. | shelle82m | 29 seconds |
| 6 Shadow Explorers | ||
| 17. | jonny | 34 seconds |
| 8 Shadow Thinkers | ||
| 26. | eiskrap | 37 seconds |
| 7 Incognito Solvers | ||
| 34. | rlivsey | 41 seconds |
| Incognito Adventurer | ||
| 36. | Nathan B | 42 seconds |
| Incognito Achiever | ||
| 38. | sarahtheduck | 43 seconds |
| 39. | hi_howareyou | 43 seconds |
| 2 Mysterious Puzzlers | ||
| 42. | ggodwin | 45 seconds |
| 4 Unidentified Thinkers | ||
| 47. | bwhough | 48 seconds |
| 48. | sannek | 48 seconds |
| Non-Member Riddler | ||
| 50. | spd | 49 seconds |
| 6 Shadow Achievers | ||
| 57. | wixardy | 52 seconds |
| 58. | jsuttonmorse | 52 seconds |
| 3 Incognito Contestants | ||
| 62. | TX101010 | 53 seconds |
| 5 Free Strategists | ||
| 68. | glucas | 55 seconds |
| 10 Stealth Enthusiasts | ||
| 79. | eltsac | 1 minute, 2 seconds |
| 3 Incognito Riddlers | ||
| 83. | kantgant | 1 minute, 4 seconds |
| 84. | MrMumbly | 1 minute, 4 seconds |
| 85. | BooBooBot | 1 minute, 5 seconds |
| 86. | steev | 1 minute, 5 seconds |
| Stealth Gamer | ||
| 88. | stefp | 1 minute, 6 seconds |
| 5 Anonymous Thinkers | ||
| 94. | Ianc | 1 minute, 8 seconds |
| 5 Unsubscribed Puzzlers | ||
| 100. | EmmaVB | 1 minute, 11 seconds |
| 3 Secret Enthusiasts | ||
| 104. | stuart | 1 minute, 13 seconds |
| 105. | sepcot | 1 minute, 13 seconds |
| 3 Visiting Victors | ||
| 109. | bdoublea | 1 minute, 15 seconds |
| 8 Unidentified Solvers | ||
| 118. | Ulnagar | 1 minute, 20 seconds |
| 2 Hidden Gamers | ||
| 121. | bumblefett | 1 minute, 22 seconds |
| 2 Undisclosed Contestants | ||
| 124. | liqrtech | 1 minute, 23 seconds |
| 3 Non-Paying Solvers | ||
| 128. | JeremyK | 1 minute, 24 seconds |
| 129. | JudyC | 1 minute, 24 seconds |
| 130. | juri | 1 minute, 25 seconds |
| 5 Free Achievers | ||
| 136. | JSlo | 1 minute, 28 seconds |
| 137. | robbinamsterdam | 1 minute, 28 seconds |
| Incognito Victor | ||
| 139. | Andrew Kemp | 1 minute, 31 seconds |
| 9 Non-Member Strategists | ||
| 149. | jc_cam | 1 minute, 42 seconds |
| 7 Mystery Competitors | ||
| 157. | dswallow | 1 minute, 50 seconds |
| 3 Unidentified Strategists | ||
| 161. | trewin | 1 minute, 53 seconds |
| 7 Visiting Contestants | ||
| 169. | nrock2277 | 2 minutes, 9 seconds |
| 2 Shadow Explorers | ||
| 172. | Marcintosh | 2 minutes, 10 seconds |
| 173. | scottaw | 2 minutes, 10 seconds |
| 174. | JonathanB | 2 minutes, 10 seconds |
| 3 Mysterious Adventurers | ||
| 178. | mythgard | 2 minutes, 13 seconds |
| 3 Anonymous Contestants | ||
| 182. | Diamond_Dog | 2 minutes, 18 seconds |
| 183. | AGS | 2 minutes, 21 seconds |
| 3 Unsubscribed Solvers | ||
| 187. | Mark S | 2 minutes, 34 seconds |
| 188. | juska | 2 minutes, 35 seconds |
| 189. | aburtch | 2 minutes, 40 seconds |
| 9 Anonymous Competitors | ||
| 199. | Bigmike | 2 minutes, 50 seconds |
| 7 Hidden Enthusiasts | ||
| 207. | coachwatson | 3 minutes, 18 seconds |
| 5 Mystery Strategists | ||
| 213. | offput | 3 minutes, 38 seconds |
| 6 Mystery Contestants | ||
| 220. | Birdie | 4 minutes, 0 seconds |
| 9 Anonymous Enthusiasts | ||
| 230. | onePageAtATime | 4 minutes, 53 seconds |
| 231. | solar | 4 minutes, 57 seconds |
| 9 Unsubscribed Thinkers | ||
| 241. | engilbertson | 6 minutes, 12 seconds |
| 10 Non-Paying Gamers | ||
| 252. | alloc | 8 minutes, 1 second |
| Non-Member Player | ||
| 254. | Allison | 8 minutes, 58 seconds |
| 18 Hidden Contestants | ||
| 273. | holgr | 123 hours, 25 minutes, 11 seconds |