| Rank | Who | Time |
| 3 Non-Member Strategists | ||
| 4. | raccoona | 32 seconds |
| 5. | natbudin ⭐ | 33 seconds |
| Anonymous Strategist | ||
| 7. | timkingman ⭐ | 34 seconds |
| 2 Non-Paying Gamers | ||
| 10. | DennisB ⭐ | 35 seconds |
| Mystery Solver | ||
| 12. | zachw ⭐ | 36 seconds |
| 13. | tylerb ⭐ | 37 seconds |
| 2 Unknown Achievers | ||
| 16. | EmmaVB ⭐ | 38 seconds |
| 2 Free Thinkers | ||
| 19. | dmoren ⭐ | 39 seconds |
| 20. | seanl ⭐ | 39 seconds |
| Hidden Strategist | ||
| 22. | k._pow ⭐ | 40 seconds |
| 2 Incognito Adventurers | ||
| 25. | kim ⭐ | 41 seconds |
| 2 Stealth Riddlers | ||
| 28. | nathanjliu ⭐ | 42 seconds |
| 29. | Andrew Kemp ⭐ | 42 seconds |
| 30. | TomFrog | 42 seconds |
| 4 Incognito Adventurers | ||
| 35. | marramgrass | 44 seconds |
| 36. | Edubbs | 44 seconds |
| 4 Mystery Contestants | ||
| 41. | peterk ⭐ | 46 seconds |
| 4 Mysterious Competitors | ||
| 46. | otter ⭐ | 48 seconds |
| 3 Incognito Enthusiasts | ||
| 50. | eiskrap ⭐ | 49 seconds |
| 6 Mystery Puzzlers | ||
| 57. | stuart ⭐ | 50 seconds |
| 14 Mystery Thinkers | ||
| 72. | lex 👑 | 53 seconds |
| Mystery Solver | ||
| 74. | robbinamsterdam | 54 seconds |
| 5 Shadow Explorers | ||
| 80. | ACM | 55 seconds |
| 3 Incognito Puzzlers | ||
| 84. | Amj501 | 56 seconds |
| 85. | offput | 56 seconds |
| 3 Incognito Achievers | ||
| 89. | rebecca | 57 seconds |
| 3 Unknown Contestants | ||
| 93. | jonny ⭐ | 58 seconds |
| 94. | glucas | 58 seconds |
| 95. | TRezendes ⭐ | 58 seconds |
| 9 Stealth Explorers | ||
| 105. | Bigmike ⭐ | 1 minute, 0 seconds |
| 106. | undercarbonated | 1 minute, 0 seconds |
| 107. | vanguard_spaceship | 1 minute, 0 seconds |
| 5 Mysterious Adventurers | ||
| 113. | JSlo | 1 minute, 1 second |
| 8 Hidden Enthusiasts | ||
| 122. | aburtch | 1 minute, 2 seconds |
| 123. | tbridge ⭐ | 1 minute, 2 seconds |
| 3 Unknown Victors | ||
| 127. | adamqp ⭐ | 1 minute, 3 seconds |
| 128. | Millon | 1 minute, 3 seconds |
| Incognito Puzzler | ||
| 130. | eltsac ⭐ | 1 minute, 4 seconds |
| 12 Unknown Adventurers | ||
| 143. | billo ⭐ | 1 minute, 6 seconds |
| 144. | krizzmp ⭐ | 1 minute, 6 seconds |
| 5 Non-Paying Challengers | ||
| 150. | Verso | 1 minute, 7 seconds |
| 3 Stealth Participants | ||
| 154. | Frankybeenz | 1 minute, 8 seconds |
| 6 Free Enthusiasts | ||
| 161. | Essiek55 | 1 minute, 9 seconds |
| 4 Stealth Participants | ||
| 166. | elkgirl | 1 minute, 10 seconds |
| 9 Non-Paying Enthusiasts | ||
| 176. | godofbiscuits | 1 minute, 11 seconds |
| 177. | sepcot ⭐ | 1 minute, 11 seconds |
| Non-Member Enthusiast | ||
| 179. | holgr | 1 minute, 12 seconds |
| 180. | _brianhamilton | 1 minute, 12 seconds |
| 8 Unsubscribed Challengers | ||
| 189. | Swifty | 1 minute, 13 seconds |
| 190. | dswallow | 1 minute, 13 seconds |
| 191. | thumpre | 1 minute, 13 seconds |
| 36 Incognito Explorers | ||
| 228. | yitz | 1 minute, 20 seconds |
| 229. | Peter | 1 minute, 20 seconds |
| 230. | quailman | 1 minute, 20 seconds |
| 4 Unregistered Adventurers | ||
| 235. | Pdkoenig | 1 minute, 21 seconds |
| 10 Incognito Achievers | ||
| 246. | AGS | 1 minute, 23 seconds |
| 5 Undisclosed Strategists | ||
| 252. | ned | 1 minute, 24 seconds |
| 7 Shadow Thinkers | ||
| 260. | flyingout ⭐ | 1 minute, 25 seconds |
| 2 Secret Participants | ||
| 263. | JeremyK | 1 minute, 26 seconds |
| 3 Anonymous Gamers | ||
| 267. | John ⭐ | 1 minute, 27 seconds |
| 26 Mystery Riddlers | ||
| 294. | PhilStollery | 1 minute, 36 seconds |
| 3 Mysterious Thinkers | ||
| 298. | bflock | 1 minute, 38 seconds |
| 299. | Ianc | 1 minute, 39 seconds |
| 6 Unsubscribed Gamers | ||
| 306. | sww | 1 minute, 41 seconds |
| 6 Anonymous Competitors | ||
| 313. | agiletortoise | 1 minute, 44 seconds |
| 12 Visiting Explorers | ||
| 326. | steev ⭐ | 1 minute, 50 seconds |
| 2 Mysterious Explorers | ||
| 329. | mclazarus | 1 minute, 52 seconds |
| 330. | simoneconnola | 1 minute, 52 seconds |
| 16 Unregistered Challengers | ||
| 347. | kricket5687 ⭐ | 2 minutes, 0 seconds |
| 24 Stealth Riddlers | ||
| 372. | merlinthp ⭐ | 2 minutes, 15 seconds |
| 2 Mystery Strategists | ||
| 375. | Dez | 2 minutes, 17 seconds |
| Mystery Riddler | ||
| 377. | Mark Tomas ⭐ | 2 minutes, 18 seconds |
| 8 Undisclosed Competitors | ||
| 386. | Existopher | 2 minutes, 23 seconds |
| 6 Unsubscribed Adventurers | ||
| 393. | BigTrouble | 2 minutes, 33 seconds |
| Unidentified Contestant | ||
| 395. | mythgard | 2 minutes, 34 seconds |
| 15 Hidden Strategists | ||
| 411. | jswright61 | 3 minutes, 6 seconds |
| 412. | leoncowle ⭐ | 3 minutes, 9 seconds |
| 29 Hidden Victors | ||
| 442. | scottaw | 6 minutes, 32 seconds |
| 20 Mystery Gamers | ||
| 463. | bob209 | 18 hours, 48 minutes, 56 seconds |