| Rank | Who | Time |
| 4 Mystery Thinkers | ||
| 5. | Edubbs | 22 seconds |
| 9 Hidden Participants | ||
| 15. | dmoren | 27 seconds |
| Hidden Strategist | ||
| 17. | sepcot | 28 seconds |
| Non-Member Competitor | ||
| 19. | ACM | 29 seconds |
| 20. | kricket5687 | 29 seconds |
| Stealth Puzzler | ||
| 22. | lex | 32 seconds |
| 9 Non-Member Strategists | ||
| 32. | LaurenSKF | 35 seconds |
| 33. | raccoona | 35 seconds |
| 34. | TomFrog | 35 seconds |
| 5 Mysterious Thinkers | ||
| 40. | glucas | 36 seconds |
| 41. | Grumpy | 36 seconds |
| 3 Hidden Strategists | ||
| 45. | marramgrass | 37 seconds |
| 46. | timkingman | 37 seconds |
| 6 Incognito Victors | ||
| 53. | thumpre | 38 seconds |
| 6 Mystery Adventurers | ||
| 60. | Andrew Kemp ⭐ | 39 seconds |
| 6 Mysterious Strategists | ||
| 67. | jonny | 40 seconds |
| 8 Non-Paying Players | ||
| 76. | billo | 41 seconds |
| 77. | zachw | 41 seconds |
| 8 Free Gamers | ||
| 86. | holgr | 43 seconds |
| 87. | eiskrap | 43 seconds |
| 5 Unknown Achievers | ||
| 93. | seanl | 44 seconds |
| 6 Shadow Riddlers | ||
| 100. | Ianc | 45 seconds |
| 7 Shadow Solvers | ||
| 108. | Amj501 | 46 seconds |
| 109. | nathanjliu | 46 seconds |
| 110. | robbinamsterdam | 46 seconds |
| 9 Mysterious Riddlers | ||
| 120. | brian | 48 seconds |
| 121. | yitz | 48 seconds |
| 6 Non-Paying Gamers | ||
| 128. | adamqp | 49 seconds |
| 129. | mrakes | 49 seconds |
| 130. | tylerb | 49 seconds |
| 131. | mattbirchler | 49 seconds |
| 132. | EmmaVB ⭐ | 49 seconds |
| 18 Non-Member Players | ||
| 151. | k._pow | 51 seconds |
| 20 Unknown Thinkers | ||
| 172. | leoncowle | 56 seconds |
| 4 Mysterious Players | ||
| 177. | bflock | 57 seconds |
| 10 Visiting Gamers | ||
| 188. | Frankybeenz | 59 seconds |
| 189. | Millon | 59 seconds |
| 190. | rebecca | 59 seconds |
| 3 Non-Member Challengers | ||
| 194. | agiletortoise | 1 minute, 0 seconds |
| 195. | mclazarus | 1 minute, 0 seconds |
| 20 Mysterious Enthusiasts | ||
| 216. | steev ⭐ | 1 minute, 4 seconds |
| 217. | eltsac | 1 minute, 4 seconds |
| 16 Incognito Solvers | ||
| 234. | peterk | 1 minute, 7 seconds |
| 5 Unknown Competitors | ||
| 240. | dswallow | 1 minute, 8 seconds |
| 6 Unregistered Challengers | ||
| 247. | JeremyK | 1 minute, 9 seconds |
| 248. | flyingout | 1 minute, 9 seconds |
| 3 Secret Competitors | ||
| 252. | stuart | 1 minute, 10 seconds |
| 253. | JSlo | 1 minute, 10 seconds |
| 3 Anonymous Players | ||
| 257. | Swifty | 1 minute, 11 seconds |
| 258. | merlinthp | 1 minute, 11 seconds |
| 5 Unregistered Players | ||
| 264. | tbridge | 1 minute, 13 seconds |
| 35 Unsubscribed Enthusiasts | ||
| 300. | Bigmike | 1 minute, 24 seconds |
| 7 Stealth Gamers | ||
| 308. | BigTrouble | 1 minute, 27 seconds |
| 309. | undercarbonated | 1 minute, 27 seconds |
| 10 Unsubscribed Solvers | ||
| 320. | PhilStollery | 1 minute, 31 seconds |
| 321. | Peter | 1 minute, 31 seconds |
| 5 Visiting Riddlers | ||
| 327. | K^2 | 1 minute, 33 seconds |
| 5 Undisclosed Players | ||
| 333. | Existopher | 1 minute, 38 seconds |
| 9 Anonymous Contestants | ||
| 343. | heyitsdiggy | 1 minute, 42 seconds |
| 4 Free Puzzlers | ||
| 348. | otter | 1 minute, 45 seconds |
| 4 Visiting Competitors | ||
| 353. | elkgirl | 1 minute, 49 seconds |
| 23 Mystery Enthusiasts | ||
| 377. | offput | 2 minutes, 7 seconds |
| 378. | mythgard | 2 minutes, 12 seconds |
| 7 Stealth Contestants | ||
| 386. | TRezendes 👑 | 2 minutes, 37 seconds |
| 387. | scottaw | 2 minutes, 38 seconds |
| 3 Shadow Enthusiasts | ||
| 391. | Dez | 2 minutes, 50 seconds |
| 24 Mystery Contestants | ||
| 416. | ned | 7 minutes, 59 seconds |
| 9 Incognito Thinkers | ||
| 426. | AGS | 2 hours, 39 minutes, 18 seconds |
| Shadow Victor | ||
| 428. | bob209 | 131 hours, 41 minutes, 16 seconds |