| Rank | Who | Time |
| Incognito Puzzler | ||
| 2. | TomFrog | 30 seconds |
| 14 Shadow Enthusiasts | ||
| 17. | marramgrass | 46 seconds |
| 2 Mystery Enthusiasts | ||
| 20. | ACM | 48 seconds |
| 2 Secret Competitors | ||
| 23. | billo | 50 seconds |
| 2 Hidden Contestants | ||
| 26. | glucas ⭐ | 51 seconds |
| 27. | Pdkoenig | 51 seconds |
| Secret Achiever | ||
| 29. | LaurenSKF | 52 seconds |
| Mystery Challenger | ||
| 31. | jonny | 53 seconds |
| 32. | otter | 53 seconds |
| 7 Mystery Solvers | ||
| 40. | dmoren | 56 seconds |
| 3 Secret Achievers | ||
| 44. | k._pow | 58 seconds |
| Anonymous Victor | ||
| 46. | simoneconnola | 59 seconds |
| 3 Hidden Challengers | ||
| 50. | sepcot | 1 minute, 0 seconds |
| Free Achiever | ||
| 52. | stuart | 1 minute, 1 second |
| 53. | eltsac | 1 minute, 1 second |
| 15 Mysterious Players | ||
| 69. | undercarbonated | 1 minute, 4 seconds |
| 5 Secret Achievers | ||
| 75. | tylerb ⭐ | 1 minute, 5 seconds |
| 3 Non-Member Challengers | ||
| 79. | Amj501 | 1 minute, 6 seconds |
| 80. | bflock | 1 minute, 7 seconds |
| 81. | peterk | 1 minute, 7 seconds |
| 6 Incognito Adventurers | ||
| 88. | timkingman | 1 minute, 9 seconds |
| 35 Anonymous Adventurers | ||
| 124. | EmmaVB ⭐ | 1 minute, 16 seconds |
| 14 Mystery Strategists | ||
| 139. | dswallow | 1 minute, 20 seconds |
| 16 Hidden Achievers | ||
| 156. | adamqp ⭐ | 1 minute, 25 seconds |
| 23 Non-Member Victors | ||
| 180. | steev ⭐ | 1 minute, 31 seconds |
| 7 Unregistered Players | ||
| 188. | Essiek55 | 1 minute, 33 seconds |
| 10 Secret Achievers | ||
| 199. | Bigmike | 1 minute, 38 seconds |
| 200. | elkgirl | 1 minute, 38 seconds |
| 201. | rebecca | 1 minute, 38 seconds |
| 12 Unsubscribed Solvers | ||
| 214. | eiskrap | 1 minute, 42 seconds |
| 3 Free Solvers | ||
| 218. | holgr | 1 minute, 43 seconds |
| 219. | Grumpy | 1 minute, 43 seconds |
| 21 Non-Member Explorers | ||
| 241. | tbridge | 1 minute, 50 seconds |
| 242. | Peter ⭐ | 1 minute, 50 seconds |
| 4 Stealth Adventurers | ||
| 247. | nathanjliu | 1 minute, 53 seconds |
| 16 Mystery Adventurers | ||
| 264. | JeremyK 👑 | 2 minutes, 5 seconds |
| 8 Non-Paying Riddlers | ||
| 273. | mythgard | 2 minutes, 9 seconds |
| 6 Non-Paying Participants | ||
| 280. | GrokTime | 2 minutes, 12 seconds |
| 5 Unknown Competitors | ||
| 286. | JSlo | 2 minutes, 15 seconds |
| 8 Mystery Strategists | ||
| 295. | TRezendes | 2 minutes, 23 seconds |
| 10 Unregistered Victors | ||
| 306. | Barry | 2 minutes, 28 seconds |
| 7 Mystery Explorers | ||
| 314. | Andrew Kemp ⭐ | 2 minutes, 32 seconds |
| 315. | yitz | 2 minutes, 34 seconds |
| 4 Hidden Enthusiasts | ||
| 320. | mclazarus | 2 minutes, 38 seconds |
| 15 Shadow Solvers | ||
| 336. | John ⭐ | 3 minutes, 0 seconds |
| Secret Thinker | ||
| 338. | marshally | 3 minutes, 4 seconds |
| Shadow Player | ||
| 340. | jswright61 | 3 minutes, 5 seconds |
| 8 Unregistered Strategists | ||
| 349. | offput | 3 minutes, 17 seconds |
| Unregistered Explorer | ||
| 351. | kricket5687 ⭐ | 3 minutes, 19 seconds |
| Secret Explorer | ||
| 353. | AGS | 3 minutes, 22 seconds |
| 4 Undisclosed Contestants | ||
| 358. | jasonlfunk | 3 minutes, 30 seconds |
| 7 Unknown Solvers | ||
| 366. | flyingout | 3 minutes, 46 seconds |
| Stealth Solver | ||
| 368. | merlinthp ⭐ | 3 minutes, 54 seconds |
| 3 Incognito Riddlers | ||
| 372. | Edubbs | 4 minutes, 12 seconds |
| 3 Mystery Enthusiasts | ||
| 376. | Frankybeenz | 4 minutes, 28 seconds |
| 11 Hidden Riddlers | ||
| 388. | Dez | 5 minutes, 32 seconds |
| 5 Mystery Gamers | ||
| 394. | scottaw | 6 minutes, 25 seconds |
| 7 Unknown Thinkers | ||
| 402. | Ianc ⭐ | 8 minutes, 35 seconds |
| 13 Unknown Gamers | ||
| 416. | ned | 1 hour, 32 minutes, 57 seconds |
| 3 Incognito Achievers | ||
| 420. | robbinamsterdam | 5 hours, 1 minute, 34 seconds |
| 4 Shadow Strategists | ||
| 425. | leoncowle | 72 hours, 1 minute, 27 seconds |