| Rank | Who | Time |
| 7 Secret Enthusiasts | ||
| 8. | Dr. Ferrous | 54 seconds |
| 2 Incognito Contestants | ||
| 11. | eltsac ⭐ | 57 seconds |
| 4 Stealth Victors | ||
| 16. | iayork | 1 minute, 8 seconds |
| Mysterious Participant | ||
| 18. | adamqp 👑 | 1 minute, 10 seconds |
| 19. | scottaw ⭐ | 1 minute, 10 seconds |
| 20. | notlex | 1 minute, 10 seconds |
| 7 Non-Member Players | ||
| 28. | abrahamvegh | 1 minute, 22 seconds |
| 9 Hidden Achievers | ||
| 38. | njpozner | 1 minute, 41 seconds |
| 39. | jsuttonmorse | 1 minute, 45 seconds |
| 12 Unidentified Explorers | ||
| 52. | k._pow ⭐ | 1 minute, 58 seconds |
| 53. | drp777 | 1 minute, 58 seconds |
| 6 Stealth Solvers | ||
| 60. | JeremyK | 2 minutes, 5 seconds |
| 2 Non-Member Contestants | ||
| 63. | robbinamsterdam | 2 minutes, 19 seconds |
| 17 Unregistered Contestants | ||
| 81. | bflock | 3 minutes, 7 seconds |
| Mystery Explorer | ||
| 83. | billo | 3 minutes, 12 seconds |
| 11 Mystery Solvers | ||
| 95. | WLG | 3 minutes, 55 seconds |
| 2 Mysterious Enthusiasts | ||
| 98. | kantgant | 4 minutes, 0 seconds |
| 35 Secret Solvers | ||
| 134. | nibeck | 9 minutes, 3 seconds |
| 12 Mystery Victors | ||
| 147. | greermama | 16 minutes, 33 seconds |
| 4 Mystery Victors | ||
| 152. | kricket5687 | 21 minutes, 52 seconds |
| 14 Hidden Players | ||