| Rank | Who | Time |
| 13 Shadow Participants | ||
| 14. | scottaw | 36 seconds |
| Non-Paying Solver | ||
| 16. | wixardy | 39 seconds |
| Incognito Challenger | ||
| 18. | JeremyK | 42 seconds |
| Mystery Solver | ||
| 20. | mccllstr | 46 seconds |
| 21. | mdrichard05 | 46 seconds |
| 22. | spd | 47 seconds |
| 23. | raccoona | 48 seconds |
| 24. | holgr | 49 seconds |
| 25. | ggodwin | 49 seconds |
| 2 Stealth Participants | ||
| 28. | sepcot 👑 | 50 seconds |
| 4 Shadow Challengers | ||
| 33. | Marcintosh | 56 seconds |
| 34. | sem | 56 seconds |
| 2 Anonymous Solvers | ||
| 37. | charlesa | 58 seconds |
| 5 Unregistered Competitors | ||
| 43. | kantgant | 1 minute, 2 seconds |
| 6 Non-Member Gamers | ||
| 50. | rlivsey | 1 minute, 5 seconds |
| 6 Hidden Participants | ||
| 57. | stuart | 1 minute, 10 seconds |
| 8 Incognito Riddlers | ||
| 66. | Bigmike | 1 minute, 21 seconds |
| 67. | Andrew Kemp | 1 minute, 21 seconds |
| 3 Unsubscribed Strategists | ||
| 71. | bumblefett | 1 minute, 24 seconds |
| 72. | shelle82m | 1 minute, 24 seconds |
| 7 Unregistered Thinkers | ||
| 80. | Swifty | 1 minute, 32 seconds |
| Mysterious Gamer | ||
| 82. | TX101010 | 1 minute, 33 seconds |
| 3 Shadow Enthusiasts | ||
| 86. | jonny | 1 minute, 34 seconds |
| 6 Hidden Solvers | ||
| 93. | MrMumbly | 1 minute, 45 seconds |
| 94. | reaganmesser | 1 minute, 46 seconds |
| 95. | glucas | 1 minute, 47 seconds |
| 96. | JSlo | 1 minute, 47 seconds |
| 8 Visiting Contestants | ||
| 105. | leoncowle | 1 minute, 59 seconds |
| 106. | mythgard | 2 minutes, 1 second |
| 107. | rebecca | 2 minutes, 2 seconds |
| 25 Anonymous Enthusiasts | ||
| 133. | coachwatson | 2 minutes, 46 seconds |
| 134. | robbinamsterdam | 2 minutes, 47 seconds |
| Mysterious Achiever | ||
| 136. | eltsac | 2 minutes, 49 seconds |
| 5 Hidden Gamers | ||
| 142. | Mark S | 3 minutes, 4 seconds |
| Visiting Competitor | ||
| 144. | bwhough | 3 minutes, 12 seconds |
| 4 Unknown Players | ||
| 149. | Ianc | 3 minutes, 30 seconds |
| 8 Free Riddlers | ||
| 158. | jsuttonmorse | 3 minutes, 48 seconds |
| Visiting Riddler | ||
| 160. | JudyC | 3 minutes, 57 seconds |
| 7 Incognito Adventurers | ||
| 168. | juska | 4 minutes, 16 seconds |
| 45 Anonymous Participants | ||
| 214. | offput | 12 minutes, 32 seconds |
| 2 Unregistered Riddlers | ||
| 217. | Quam | 15 minutes, 28 seconds |
| 218. | musubi | 19 minutes, 4 seconds |
| 219. | rawrdimus | 19 minutes, 49 seconds |
| 2 Secret Gamers | ||
| 222. | nrock2277 | 35 minutes, 37 seconds |
| 9 Shadow Victors | ||