| Rank | Who | Time |
| 6 Unsubscribed Riddlers | ||
| 7. | mrakes | 21 seconds |
| 7 Mystery Solvers | ||
| 15. | jonny | 24 seconds |
| 16. | adamqp | 24 seconds |
| Non-Paying Player | ||
| 18. | scottaw | 25 seconds |
| 3 Unsubscribed Enthusiasts | ||
| 22. | Ani Friedman | 26 seconds |
| 23. | Bigmike | 26 seconds |
| 24. | marramgrass | 26 seconds |
| 25. | Khemileon | 26 seconds |
| 3 Mystery Solvers | ||
| 29. | dmoren | 27 seconds |
| 30. | Amj501 | 27 seconds |
| Shadow Enthusiast | ||
| 32. | bwhough | 28 seconds |
| 3 Non-Paying Competitors | ||
| 36. | eiskrap | 29 seconds |
| 37. | bflock | 29 seconds |
| 38. | Millon | 29 seconds |
| 5 Anonymous Players | ||
| 44. | billo | 30 seconds |
| 12 Free Riddlers | ||
| 57. | undercarbonated | 34 seconds |
| 3 Free Adventurers | ||
| 61. | leoncowle | 36 seconds |
| 62. | EmmaVB | 36 seconds |
| 7 Anonymous Victors | ||
| 70. | LaurenSKF | 41 seconds |
| 71. | MsKinNJ | 41 seconds |
| 7 Mystery Participants | ||
| 79. | JSlo | 45 seconds |
| 3 Mysterious Victors | ||
| 83. | merlinthp | 46 seconds |
| 4 Stealth Participants | ||
| 88. | kantgant | 48 seconds |
| 7 Secret Enthusiasts | ||
| 96. | JeremyK | 52 seconds |
| 2 Free Enthusiasts | ||
| 99. | Dr. Ferrous 👑 | 53 seconds |
| Shadow Contestant | ||
| 101. | Swifty | 54 seconds |
| 2 Mystery Achievers | ||
| 104. | tylerb | 55 seconds |
| Shadow Solver | ||
| 106. | glucas | 56 seconds |
| 107. | TomFrog | 56 seconds |
| 108. | tbridge | 57 seconds |
| 3 Undisclosed Challengers | ||
| 112. | nathanjliu | 59 seconds |
| Free Thinker | ||
| 114. | BenRiceM | 1 minute, 1 second |
| 3 Stealth Competitors | ||
| 118. | mythgard | 1 minute, 2 seconds |
| 7 Shadow Adventurers | ||
| 126. | mclazarus | 1 minute, 5 seconds |
| 4 Free Solvers | ||
| 131. | Andrew Kemp | 1 minute, 9 seconds |
| 10 Mystery Participants | ||
| 142. | BooBooBot | 1 minute, 19 seconds |
| 11 Incognito Explorers | ||
| 154. | AGS | 1 minute, 31 seconds |
| 4 Free Players | ||
| 159. | heyitsdiggy | 1 minute, 39 seconds |
| 160. | SAT232 | 1 minute, 39 seconds |
| 161. | Ianc | 1 minute, 42 seconds |
| Free Thinker | ||
| 163. | Pdkoenig | 1 minute, 47 seconds |
| 3 Shadow Achievers | ||
| 167. | raccoona | 1 minute, 52 seconds |
| 6 Anonymous Adventurers | ||
| 174. | offput | 2 minutes, 7 seconds |
| 10 Unknown Riddlers | ||
| 185. | otter | 2 minutes, 38 seconds |
| 5 Mystery Competitors | ||
| 191. | elkgirl | 2 minutes, 48 seconds |
| 3 Unregistered Riddlers | ||
| 195. | PhilStollery | 3 minutes, 15 seconds |
| Visiting Riddler | ||
| 197. | stuart | 3 minutes, 47 seconds |
| 10 Mysterious Challengers | ||
| 208. | Mayson Lancaster | 5 minutes, 50 seconds |
| 18 Undisclosed Victors | ||
| 227. | jazzy | 199 hours, 52 minutes, 51 seconds |