| Rank | Who | Time |
| 1. | glucas | 22 seconds |
| 2. | sullust | 22 seconds |
| 3. | Ani Friedman | 24 seconds |
| 8 Non-Member Achievers | ||
| 12. | LaurenSKF | 35 seconds |
| 13. | JeremyK | 35 seconds |
| 2 Incognito Adventurers | ||
| 16. | eiskrap | 39 seconds |
| 17. | jonny | 40 seconds |
| 18. | Amj501 | 41 seconds |
| 19. | kantgant | 42 seconds |
| 5 Non-Member Challengers | ||
| 25. | dmoren | 44 seconds |
| 11 Secret Challengers | ||
| 37. | Bigmike | 53 seconds |
| 3 Unregistered Riddlers | ||
| 41. | raccoona | 55 seconds |
| 13 Hidden Strategists | ||
| 55. | nathanjliu | 1 minute, 3 seconds |
| 56. | tylerb | 1 minute, 3 seconds |
| Mystery Competitor | ||
| 58. | BenRiceM | 1 minute, 6 seconds |
| 9 Anonymous Gamers | ||
| 68. | Jono | 1 minute, 9 seconds |
| 6 Secret Challengers | ||
| 75. | merlinthp | 1 minute, 13 seconds |
| Hidden Riddler | ||
| 77. | mrakes | 1 minute, 14 seconds |
| 78. | Essiek55 | 1 minute, 14 seconds |
| 79. | mythgard | 1 minute, 14 seconds |
| Unregistered Victor | ||
| 81. | TomFrog | 1 minute, 15 seconds |
| 5 Unidentified Challengers | ||
| 87. | seanl | 1 minute, 20 seconds |
| 88. | yitz | 1 minute, 20 seconds |
| 5 Non-Paying Contestants | ||
| 94. | Grumpy | 1 minute, 25 seconds |
| 7 Incognito Players | ||
| 102. | JSlo | 1 minute, 29 seconds |
| 3 Anonymous Puzzlers | ||
| 106. | billo | 1 minute, 32 seconds |
| Mystery Enthusiast | ||
| 108. | marramgrass | 1 minute, 33 seconds |
| 25 Stealth Participants | ||
| 134. | Spol | 2 minutes, 13 seconds |
| 14 Mystery Players | ||
| 149. | MsKinNJ | 2 minutes, 30 seconds |
| 150. | Ianc 👑 | 2 minutes, 33 seconds |
| 15 Incognito Puzzlers | ||
| 166. | John | 3 minutes, 2 seconds |
| 167. | Andrew Kemp | 3 minutes, 4 seconds |
| 168. | kodi | 3 minutes, 6 seconds |
| 3 Shadow Thinkers | ||
| 172. | adamqp | 3 minutes, 30 seconds |
| 8 Stealth Adventurers | ||
| 181. | peterk | 4 minutes, 2 seconds |
| 7 Hidden Thinkers | ||
| 189. | bflock | 4 minutes, 50 seconds |
| 17 Secret Adventurers | ||
| 207. | Squeez1e | 6 minutes, 38 seconds |
| 208. | joekissell | 6 minutes, 44 seconds |
| Mystery Explorer | ||
| 210. | solar | 6 minutes, 59 seconds |
| 19 Unknown Puzzlers | ||
| 230. | Miraz | 28 minutes, 56 seconds |
| 6 Hidden Thinkers | ||